Promise of Reason

Let us convert emotional issues of Indian politics and society into rational discussion

Reorganizing South Asia as it should be – introduction

This entry is part 1 of 2 in the series Reorganizing South Asia

Regions of North-western South Asia

regions of south asia, india, pakistan, afghanistan map

Proposed National Boundaries

final proposed boundaries of pakistan, afghanistan, india

I am starting this new series on “how to reorganize the South Asia politically” so as to have maximum possibility of peace and prosperiety. Division on lines of religion has been proven wrong. Base of my analysis is ethnic character of the India-Pakistan-Afghanistan-Nepal-Sri Lanka-Bangladesh-Bhutan. This analysis is based on data collected over the time and my understanding of south asia, everybody is welcome to put in their views as comments. Later I plan to bring it out as free ebook. Read the rest of this entry »

Why has the BJP been losing its support steadily among the youth and urban educated middle class?

BJP for youth

This post is by Ratnakar Sadasyula, our guest contributor. Ratnakar is an IT professional. Please welcome him on POR.

The BJP’s spectacular rise in the 90’s was due to the enthusiastic backing of the younger sections of the population, during that time. The BJP had a large support from the younger educated professionals, the college going students, and people in the 20-40 age category. While the older generation still voted for the Congress, a major part of the BJP’s support base came from the youth. For a Generation, fed up with the shenigans of the Congress, the failure of “champagne socialism” and “sham secularism”, the BJP seemed the best alternative. The BJP’s right wing Hindutva ideology had large scale support among the urban educated middle classes, while its espousal of a capitalist economy enthused the youth. The reason why youth, including myself, supported the BJP in large numbers was its no nonsense stance on internal security and the country’s safety. Many ex Defence officers joined the BJP, impressed by the party’s discipline, its decorum. While there essentially was not much difference between Congress and BJP on economic policy in the 90’s, the difference was pronounced on other issues, like relations with US, more friendly policy with Israel, Uniform Civil Code, repeal of Article 370, which did really attract the youth. Read the rest of this entry »

5 Reasons why it is best time to start an all-out military campaign against naxals

say no to lal salaam

So, central government has banned CPI maoist, the main outfit of maoist and naxalite activities in India. It is a much awaited action and finally government woke up when these so called revolutionaries had taken over a large part of Lalgarh. Anyways better late than never. But it should not be stopped here. Government should start an all out campaign and mind you military/para-military campaign, not a police one to flush out all the naxalites from whole country, so that a right environment of development can be created in naxal affected areas. It is the best time to do so in last 60 years and looks like universe has conspired to give us that opportunity. Government must seize it with open hands and ruthless force. Here are the reasons why it is the best time to start an all-out flush out campaign against maoist and naxalites. Read the rest of this entry »

Media neutrality in India : Problem and solution

media neutrality :POR

The problem:

Whether it is Mr. Rajdeep sardesai on CNN-IBN showing his concerns for performance of Congress party or NDTV news reporters stating their clear preferences for Left in their news items, all are sources of worry for neutral functioning of media. Media which is by its very name, not supposed to favor one party or another, seems to loosing its way. All the media persons we are discussing here are very senior reporters and thinkers as such. But problem to separate fact from the personal values and preferences is looming large on media as a whole. Read the rest of this entry »

Hopes are shattered and nightmares prevailed, UPA 250, NDA 160 : Share Your Views

lowering the flag

So, the results are out and it is exact opposite to what this blog predicted. It is a major win for congress, in every state and every part of country. All other major alliances are decisively defeated. Congress says it is a vote for development and for its crown prince Rahul Gandhi. He did revive congress in UP as promised.

Still my biggest sympathy is with BJP, which is the party I voted for. A nationalist party. It is a loss of face for BJP.
But friends, There are times in history of a nation when all seem lost and looks like wrong forces have won the final battle. But dear friends, it is just a process, which goes on and on. 5 years may be significant time period in life of a man, but in life of a nation (that too a nation like India) is just a flickr of eye.

The time after defeat is not for grief and blame-game. It is the time to introspect and start preparing to come out as winner in next battle.

Though hopes are shattered and nightmares are prevailing, the dawn will surely come. It is not the first black day of Indian history, we survived and fought back. Let us do that again.

Tell us what do you feel, comment!

West Bengal seatwise prepoll prediction by Sameer

This entry is part 11 of 11 in the series Pre-poll seatwise predictions by Promise of Reason readers

This is my prediction about how things are going to turn out in west bengal:

1. Coochbehar: Toss up ( Trinamool- AIFB)
2. Alipurduar: RSP
3. Jalpaiguri: CPI(M)
4. Darjelling: BJP
5. Raiganj: INC
6. Balurghat: Toss up
7. Maldaha Uttar: INC
8. Maldaha Dakshin: INC
9. Jangipur: INC
10. Baharampur: INC Read the rest of this entry »

Pre-poll prediction after phase 3 by Shiladitya Bose

This entry is part 10 of 11 in the series Pre-poll seatwise predictions by Promise of Reason readers

Based on feedback received from the ground in some states as well as newspaper, TV reports, web blogs and discussions during the 3 phases of “India Votes 2009”, my state wise estimate is given below. I would request all readers to give your valuable inputs also.

Phases I-II were certainly advantageous to NDA. There were some setbacks to the alliance during Phase-III in the states of Karnataka and Gujarat. Overall the 3 phases has put NDA ahead.

But the alliance has little to consolidate upon in the subsequent 2 phases, which may be limited to small gains in Himachal, Western UP, Haryana, and Delhi. It should now focus on increasing the losses of UPA by either cutting down UPA votes, strategically transferring its votes to non UPA parties especially in TN and WB and finally restricting its losses in Rajasthan and Punjab. In fact if BJP helps Left restrict its losses in WB and Kerela, it would be an advantage to NDA as it would directly affect UPA numbers. Read the rest of this entry »

Chakresh Mishra (India) : Mechanical Engineer, Socio-political Analyst, Aspiring Diplomat

What do you like

Recent Series of blog

Twitter Sideblog: Follow me on twitter ------------->

  • at my home and end enjoying weekend 5 days ago
  • #india : Formation of new states: Criteria and right path http://promiseofreason.com/formation-of-new-states-criteria-and-right-path/ 2009-12-16
  • WPWebHost is giving away 10 iPhones in Twitter Giveaway from 28 Sep. Retweet http://bit.ly/IStTl to win 1 year FREE WordPress Hosting now! 2009-09-18
  • to update to snow leopard or not, confused, checking out apps unsupported yet. 2009-09-16
  • India, China are like brothers: Chinese Consul General; who has forgotten end of Hindi-chini bhai bhai ...... Indian gov, plz do the needful 2009-09-15
  • Today's, or better tonight's resolution: will not watch any sitcom on my laptop for next 5 years. Goodbye Friends/taahm/himym/tbbt 2009-09-07
  • There is leadership/intelligentsia crisis in India and I am watching two and a half man for last two days. what a shame! :( 2009-09-07
  • Ironically, the year of his greatest political triumph has ended in personal tragedy for YSR 2009-09-03
  • So one more young and promising leader of India dies, no miracle this time. YSR did many good work. Silence for him :( 2009-09-03
  • Indian Politics is in such a leadership crisis that no party really knows what is mood of public or indian public itself is confused? 2009-09-01
  • OH People Will forget what you said. People will forget what you did, but People will Never forget how you made them feel. 2009-08-30
  • Rajnath Singh should go back to UP and help ailing BJP there. I am sure, he can be a mass leader and can balance caste equation also 2009-08-29
  • Oh, left wants to redistribute wealth without generating it. What a V for Vendetta fiasco :) 2009-08-27
  • Looking for some internal democracy in The Great Indian Democratic Parties ...... have you seen it? 2009-08-23
  • If Rakhi Sawant was PM: there would be very little to hide in government affairs :) 2009-08-21
  • #india : India will be what we are http://bit.ly/4wegZ7 2009-08-20
  • BJP must know that place of right wing party is still vacant in Indian politics. Don't fool people by trying to be 2nd congress 2009-08-20
  • BJP chintan baithak: Ramlal ji from RSS seems to be dictating terms in there. Time for RSS to take charge and do something abt mess in BJP 2009-08-20
  • Jaswant Singh episode: Is it really the book or earlier spat that made Jaswant miserable and Jaitley so happy? 2009-08-20
  • "What would be the use of immortality to a person who cannot use well a half an hour." Ralph Waldo Emerson 2009-08-10
  • More updates...

Indian Politics Forums Latest Discussions